Обсуждение: case sensitivity in PQExecPrepared

I noticed a curious thing (not sure if by design or not).

While using the PQExecPrepared interface, the statement name passed to
the function (as a const char*) has to be in lower case to get it to
work.  I kind of understand why this is, but it is kind of weird that
passing the exact same statement name to PQExecPrepared and PREPARE does
not work if it contains any upper case characters.

Just FYI.
Merlin

Merlin Moncure wrote:
> While using the PQExecPrepared interface, the statement name passed
> to the function (as a const char*) has to be in lower case to get it
> to work.  I kind of understand why this is, but it is kind of weird
> that passing the exact same statement name to PQExecPrepared and
> PREPARE does not work if it contains any upper case characters.

PQExecPrepared is used in C programs, PREPARE is used in SQL programs.  
I think it's fairly obvious that those use different syntax rules.

-- 
Peter Eisentraut
http://developer.postgresql.org/~petere/

Peter Eisentraut wrote:
> Merlin Moncure wrote:
> > While using the PQExecPrepared interface, the statement name passed
> > to the function (as a const char*) has to be in lower case to get it
> > to work.  I kind of understand why this is, but it is kind of weird
> > that passing the exact same statement name to PQExecPrepared and
> > PREPARE does not work if it contains any upper case characters.
>
> PQExecPrepared is used in C programs, PREPARE is used in SQL programs.
> I think it's fairly obvious that those use different syntax rules.

Well, yes :)  Just to be absolutely clear what I mean, the following
will fail (pseudocode, but you get the idea):

char stmt[] = "prepare X as select 0()";
PQexec(c, "execute X"); <-- works
PQexecPrepared(c, "X" [...]); <-- fails

You are saying this is the correct and expected behavior?

Merlin

Merlin Moncure wrote:
> Well, yes :)  Just to be absolutely clear what I mean, the following
> will fail (pseudocode, but you get the idea):
>
> char stmt[] = "prepare X as select 0()";
> PQexec(c, "execute X"); <-- works
> PQexecPrepared(c, "X" [...]); <-- fails
>
> You are saying this is the correct and expected behavior?

Yes, because part of those syntax rules is that in SQL, unquoted 
identifiers are folded to lower case, but in C they are not.

-- 
Peter Eisentraut
http://developer.postgresql.org/~petere/