Re: csv format for psql

    Michael Paquier wrote:

> - The experience is confusing, as the psql format uses different options
> than the backend to do the same things:
> -- tuples_only instead of HEADER.
> -- fieldsep_csv instead of DELIMITER
> -- null is an equivalent of the one with the same name, which is
> actually consistent.
> -- encoding is also an equivalent of ENCODING.

That conveniently ignores the fact that "\pset format somename"
as a command doesn't take any additional option, contrary to COPY.
We can't do \pset format csv (delimiter=';')
If we choosed "delimiter" as an option name, it would have to exist
within 20 other names in the \pset namespace and then it would be
too vague, whereas "fieldsep_csv" makes it clear what it applies to.
"tuples_only" is preexisting, and I don't see how the comment that it's
not called "header" could be actionable.

Overall, you seem to posit that we should mimic the entire
COPY TO interface to implement 'psql --csv'.
But the starting point is that 'psql --csv' is just a slightly
different (safer) variant of 'psql -At', which is not concerned
at all with being consistent with COPY.
The model of the csv output format is the unaligned output format,
it's just not COPY.


Best regards,
--
Daniel Vérité
PostgreSQL-powered mailer: http://www.manitou-mail.org
Twitter: @DanielVerite