On Aug 4, 2008, at 1:04 PM, daveg wrote:
> Ok, that is a different use case where an error seems very useful.
> What
> about slightly extending the proposal to have the severity of
> exceeding
> the limit configurable too. Something like:
>
> costestimate_limit = 1000000000 # default 0 to ignore limit
> costestimate_limit_severity = error # debug, notice, warning,
> error
I very much like this idea, and I would definitely use something like
this on our production oltp app. We had a case recently where a query
joining two large tables was very fast 99.9% of the time (i.e., a few
ms), but for particular, rare key combinations the planner would make
a poor choice turning into a multi-minute monster. It ran longer than
the web server timeout, and the client was programmed to retry on
error, essentially causing a database DoS.
The monster version of the plan had an outrageous cost estimate, many
orders of magnitude higher than any regular app query, and would be
easy to peg using even a crudely chosen limit value.
The problem was first mitigated by setting a query timeout a little
longer than the web server timeout (since the query results are
discarded for anything running longer), but even this was not a
solution, since the client would retry on timeout, still keeping the
db too busy. The real solution was to not do the query, but it would
have been better to identify this via ERRORs in the logs than by the
database becoming saturated in the middle of the day.
For our application it is far better for an expensive query to be
rejected outright than to attempt to run it in vain. Just thought I'd
throw that out as anecdotal support.
-Casey