Re: Assert failure on 'list_member_ptr(rel->joininfo, restrictinfo)'

Hi Alexander,

On Sun, Dec 24, 2023 at 5:32 PM Alexander Korotkov <aekorotkov@gmail.com> wrote:
>
>
> Thank you Ashutosh for your work on this matter.  With a large number of partitions, it definitely makes sense to
reduceboth Bitmapset's size as well as the number of Bitmapsets. 
>
> I've checked the patchset [1] with your test suite to check the memory consumption.  The results are in the table
below.
>
> query                             | no patch   | patch      | no self-join removal
> ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
> 2-way join, non partitioned       | 14792      | 15208      | 29152
> 2-way join, no partitionwise join | 19519576   | 19519576   | 19519576
> 2-way join, partitionwise join    | 40851968   | 40851968   | 40851968
> 3-way join, non partitioned       | 20632      | 21784      | 79376
> 3-way join, no partitionwise join | 45227224   | 45227224   | 45227224
> 3-way join, partitionwise join    | 151655144  | 151655144  | 151655144
> 4-way join, non partitioned       | 25816      | 27736      | 209128
> 4-way join, no partitionwise join | 83540712   | 83540712   | 83540712
> 4-way join, partitionwise join    | 463960088  | 463960088  | 463960088
> 5-way join, non partitioned       | 31000      | 33720      | 562552
> 5-way join, no partitionwise join | 149284376  | 149284376  | 149284376
> 5-way join, partitionwise join    | 1663896608 | 1663896608 | 1663896608
>
>
> The most noticeable thing for me is that self-join removal doesn't work with partitioned tables.  I think this is the
directionfor future work on this subject.  In non-partitioned cases, patchset gives a small memory overhead.  However,
thememory consumption is still much less than it is without the self-join removal.  So, removing the join still lowers
memoryconsumption even if it copies some Bitmapsets.  Given that patchset [1] is required for the correctness of memory
manipulationsin Bitmapsets during join removals, I'm going to push it if there are no objections. 

I am missing the link between this work and the self join work. Can
you please provide me relevant pointers?

--
Best Wishes,
Ashutosh Bapat