Re: Report planning memory in EXPLAIN ANALYZE

On Fri, Dec 1, 2023 at 8:27 AM Andrei Lepikhov
<a.lepikhov@postgrespro.ru> wrote:
>
> On 30/11/2023 18:40, Alvaro Herrera wrote:
> > Well, SUMMARY is enabled by default with ANALYZE, and I'd rather not
> > have planner memory consumption displayed by default with all EXPLAIN
> > ANALYZEs.  So yeah, I still think this deserves its own option.
> >
> > But let's hear others' opinions on this point.  I'm only one vote here.
>
> I agree; it should be disabled by default. The fact that memory
> consumption outputs with byte precision (very uncomfortable for
> perception) is a sign that the primary audience is developers and for
> debugging purposes.

That's 2 vs 1. Here's patch with MEMORY option added. Replying to
Alvaro's earlier relevant comments.

> If EXPLAIN (MEMORY) is added, then probably auto_explain needs a
> corresponding flag, and doc updates.

auto_explain does not implement planner_hook and hence can not gather
information about planner's memory usage. So no new flag and doc
update to auto_explain. I have added a comment auto_explain.c but
probably even that's not needed. We are considering this option only
for developers and auto_explain is largely for users. So I didn't feel
like adding an implementation of planner_hook in auto_explain and use
MEMORY option. If we feel that planner's memory usage report is useful
in auto_explain, it should easy to do that in future.

> The EXPLAIN docs (explain.sgml) need an update to mention the new flag
> and the new output, too.

Done.

0001 is as is except explain.out and explain.sgml changes reverted.

0002 following changes. It's a separate patch for ease of review.
a. implements MEMORY option, adds tests in explain.sql and also
updates explain.sgml.
b. show_planning_memory renamed to show_planner_memory to be in sync
with the output
c. small indentation change by pgindent.

--
Best Wishes,
Ashutosh Bapat