Re: There should be a way to use the force flag when restoring databases

> On 19 Jul 2023, at 19:28, Gurjeet Singh <gurjeet@singh.im> wrote:
>
> On Tue, Jul 18, 2023 at 12:53 AM Joan <aseques@gmail.com> wrote:
>>
>> Since posgres 13 there's the option to do a FORCE when dropping a database (so it disconnects current users)
Documentationhere: https://www.postgresql.org/docs/current/sql-dropdatabase.html 
>>
>> I am currently using dir format for the output
>>   pg_dump -d "bdname" -F d -j 4 -v -f /tmp/dir
>>
>> And restoring the database with
>>  pg_restore -d postgres -C -c --exit-on-error -F d -j 3 -v /tmp/dir
>>
>> Having an option to add the FORCE option to either the generated dump by pg_dump, or in the pg_restore would be very
usefulwhen restoring the databases to another servers so it would avoid having to do scripting. 
>>
>> In my specific case I am using this to refresh periodically a development environment with data from production
serversfor a small database (~200M). 
>
> Making force-drop a part of pg_dump output may be dangerous, and not
> provide much flexibility at restore time.
>
> Adding a force option to pg_restore feels like providing the right tradeoff.
>
> The docs for 'pg_restore --create` say "Create the database before
> restoring into it. If --clean is also specified, drop and recreate the
> target database before connecting to it."
>
> If we provided a force option, it may then additionally say: "If the
> --clean and --force options are specified, DROP DATABASE ... WITH
> FORCE command will be used to drop the database."

pg_restore --clean refers to dropping any pre-existing database objects and not
just databases, but --force would only apply to databases.

I wonder if it's worth complicating pg_restore with that when running dropdb
--force before pg_restore is an option for those wanting to use WITH FORCE.

--
Daniel Gustafsson