Re: [PATCH] Largeobject access controls

KaiGai Kohei <kaigai@ak.jp.nec.com> writes:
> The attached patch provides access control features on largeobject.
> This patch adds the ownership and two permissions (SELECT and UPDATE) on
> largeobjects. The two permissions controls reader and writer accesses to
> the largeobejcts.

What about DELETE permissions?  Should we track that separately from
UPDATE?

> The CREATE USER/ROLE statement got a new option: LARGEOBJECT/NOLARGEOBJECT.
> It enables to controls whether the user can create a largeobject, or not.

I don't think this is necessary or appropriate.

> The pg_largeobject system catalog is reworked to manage its metadata.
> Actual data chunks are stored in the toast relation of pg_largeobject,

This seems like a very confusing design, and one that (a) breaks
existing code to no purpose, (b) will greatly complicate in-place
upgrade.  Instead of abusing a toast relation to do something
nonstandard, keep pg_largeobject as it is now and add a new, separate
catalog that carries ownership and permissions info for each LO OID.
        regards, tom lane