Re: dependencies for generated header files

On Tue, Aug 11, 2009 at 4:38 PM, Peter Eisentraut<peter_e@gmx.net> wrote:
> On Sunday 28 June 2009 21:21:35 Robert Haas wrote:
>> I think that our dependencies for generated header files (gram.h,
>> fmgroids.h, probes.h) are not as good as they could be.  What we do
>> right now is make src/backend/Makefile rebuild these before recursing
>> through its subdirectories.  This works OK for a top-level make, but
>> if you run make further down in the tree (like under
>> src/backend/commands) it won't necessarily rebuild everything that it
>> should.
>>
>> The attached patch moves some of this logic from src/backend/Makefile
>> to src/Makefile.global.in.  That way, if you --enable-depend and then
>> do something like "touch src/include/catalog/pg_proc.h" and then "cd
>> src/backend/commands; make vacuum.o", it rebuilds fmgroids.h and then
>> recompiles vacuum.c.  Under HEAD, it just tells you that vacuum.o is
>> up to date.
>
> I'm not convinced by this use case.  Why do you want to rebuild vacuum.o
> anyway?  If you change something, then you probably want to rebuild postgres,
> and that works fine without this change.

Well, my original motivation for developing this patch was that I
often go into a subdirectory and start hacking on a .c file and then
type make to rebuild just that subdirectory (so it's easier to see
warnings and errors).  But sometimes I would edit a relevant header
file and then the rebuild wouldn't happen.  That bugged me.  Your
mileage may vary.

> I'm concerned how this change moves random make rules into a global makefile.
> This is exacerbated by your next patch, which among other things moves the
> entire catalog list to build the various output files into Makefile.global,
> far away from its home.

*shrug*  You don't have to accept the patch, but I'm unclear as to how
make from a subdirectory will ever work reliably without something
like this.  The problem occurs when .c files have dependencies on
files that are generated by a Makefile in some other subdirectory.  So
it's not random stuff: it's the stuff where that particular thing
happens.

...Robert