Re: Add min and max execute statement time in pg_stat_statement

On 24/10/13 10:34, Marc Mamin wrote:
>>> Oscillating plan changes may fit multimodal but I don't feel that's
>>> typical.  My experience has been it's either an extremely rare plan
>>> difference or it's a shift from one plan to another over time.
>> After all, all of avg, min, max and stdev are only numerical value for predicting model. There aren't the robustness
andstrictness such as Write Ahead Logging. It resembles a weather forecast. They are still better than nothing.
 
>> It is needed a human judgment to finally suppose a cause from the numerical values. By the way, we can guess
probabilityof the value from stdev.
 
>> Therefore we can guess easily even if there is an extreme value in min/max whether it is normal or not.
>>>> What I've been gathering from my quick chat this morning is that
>>>> either you know how to characterize the distribution and then the min
>>>> max and average are useful on their own, or you need to keep track of
>>>> an histogram where all the bins are of the same size to be able to
>>>> learn what the distribution actually is.
> Hello,
>
> We have an in house reporting application doing a lot of response times graphing.
> Our experience has shown that in many cases of interest (the one you want to dig in)
> a logarithmic scale for histogram bins result in a better visualization.
> attached an example from a problematic postgres query...
>
> my 2 pences,
>
> Marc Mamin
Looks definitely bimodal in the log version, very clear!

Yes, I feel that having a 32 log binary binned histogram (as Alvaro 
Herrera suggested) would be very useful.  Especially if the size of the 
first bin can be set - as some people would like to be 100us and others 
might prefer 1ms or something else.


Cheers,
Gavin