Re: 8.4-vintage problem in postmaster.c

On 11/15/2010 03:24 PM, Alvaro Herrera wrote:
> Excerpts from Tom Lane's message of sáb nov 13 19:07:50 -0300 2010:
>> Stefan Kaltenbrunner<stefan@kaltenbrunner.cc>  writes:
>>> On 11/13/2010 06:58 PM, Tom Lane wrote:
>>>> Just looking at it, I think that the logic in canAcceptConnections got
>>>> broken by somebody in 8.4, and then broken some more in 9.0: in some
>>>> cases it will return an "okay to proceed" status without having checked
>>>> for TOOMANY children.  Was this system possibly in PM_WAIT_BACKUP or
>>>> PM_HOT_STANDBY state?  What version was actually running?
>>
>>> I don't have too many details on the actual setup (working on that) but
>>> the box in question is running 8.4.2 and had no issues before the
>>> upgrade to 8.4 (ie 8.3 was reported to work fine - so a 8.4+ breakage
>>> looks plausible).
>>
>> Well, this failure would certainly involve a flood of connection
>> attempts, so it's possible it's a pre-existing bug that they just did
>> not happen to trip over before.  But the sequence of events that I'm
>> thinking about is a smart shutdown attempt (SIGTERM to postmaster)
>> while an online backup is in progress, followed by a flood of
>> near-simultaneous connection attempts while the backup is still active.
>
> As far as I could gather from Stefan's description, I think this is
> pretty unlikely.  It seems to me that the "too many children" error
> message is very common in the 8.3 setup already, and the only reason
> they have a problem on 8.4 is that it crashes instead.

not sure if that is true - but 8.4 crashes whereas 8.3  just (seems to) 
works - the issue is still there with 8_4_STABLE...

DEBUG3 level output (last few hours - 7MB in size) is available under 
http://www.kaltenbrunner.cc/files/postgresql-2010-11-24_143513.log
From looking at the code I'm not immediatly seeing what is going wrong 
here but maybe somebody else has an idea.


Stefan