Re: lock_timeout GUC patch - Review

Marc Cousin írta:
> The Thursday 29 July 2010 13:55:38, Boszormenyi Zoltan wrote :
>
>> I fixed this by adding CheckLockTimeout() function that works like
>> CheckStatementTimeout() and ensuring that the same start time is
>> used for both deadlock_timeout and lock_timeout if both are active.
>> The preference of errors if their timeout values are equal is:
>> statement_timeout > lock_timeout > deadlock_timeout
>>
>
> As soon as lock_timeout is bigger than deadlock_timeout, it doesn't
> work, with this new version.
>
> Keeping the deadlock_timeout to 1s, when lock_timeout >= 1001,
> lock_timeout doesn't trigger anymore.
>

I missed one case when the lock_timeout_active should have been set
but the timer must not have been re-set, this caused the problem.
I blame the hot weather and having no air conditioning. The second is
now fixed. :-)

I also added one line in autovacuum.c to disable lock_timeout,
in case it's globally set in postgresq.conf as per Alvaro's comment.

Also, I made sure that only one or two timeout causes (one of
deadlock_timeout
and lock_timeout in the first case or statement_timeout plus one of the
other two)
can be active at a time. Previously I was able to trigger a segfault
with the default
1sec deadlock_timeout and lock_timeout = 999 or 1001. Effectively, the
system's
clock resolution makes the lock_timeout and deadlock_timeout equal and
RemoveFromWaitQueue() was called twice. This way it's a lot more robust.

Best regards,
Zoltán Böszörményi