Re: BUG #4340: SECURITY: Is SSL Doing Anything?

Tom Lane wrote:
> Dan Kaminsky <dan@doxpara.com> writes:
>
>> My question has been:  When you attempt to create an SSL connection to
>> database.backend.com, do you actually validate that:
>>
>
>
>> 1) The subject name of the certificate you're connecting to is
>> database.backend.com, and
>> 2) At least the basic checks (expiration, chaining back to a valid root)
>> occur?
>>
>
> [ shrug... ] We do whatever OpenSSL's default validation behavior is.
> If that's inadequate you probably ought to be taking it up with them,
> instead of trying to get downstream projects to fix it one at a time.
>
>             regards, tom lane
>
Heh, you're the one making guarantees to your users.  I'm just asking
the exact nature of those guarantees.  I agree that #2 is entirely under
the control of OpenSSL -- but I'd like to know if #1 is being satisfied,
i.e. OpenSSL knows you're looking to validate database.backend.com as
opposed to "some cert that chains back", which is a worthless security
assertion.

--Dan