Re: User Defined Types in Java

Martijn van Oosterhout wrote:
> On Thu, Feb 09, 2006 at 01:08:01PM +0100, Thomas Hallgren wrote:
>> Hi,
>> I'd like to enable UDT's written in Java and made some initial trial and 
>> error. I don't get very far. Here's what I do:
>>
>> I take the 'complex' type example described in '31.11 User-Defined 
>> Types' and change it to use Java functions (see below). But I get:
>>
>>  ERROR:  type "complex" does not exist
> 
> If you look at the code it says in a comment:
> 
>                 /*
>                  * Only C-coded functions can be I/O functions.  We enforce this
>                  * restriction here mainly to prevent littering the catalogs with
>                  * shell types due to simple typos in user-defined function
>                  * definitions.
>                  */
>  

Ouch. Any chance of getting this changed? If we can agree on a good design I'd be happy to 
implement and submit it.

> However, you could probably work around this like so:
> 
> CREATE FUNCTION dummy(cstring) RETURNS complex AS [random existing
> function] LANGUAGE INTERNAL;
> 
> This will create the shell type. You then create your other functions
> and finally the type, at which point you can delete the dummy function
> again.
> 

Great. Thanks. Then at least I can test if what I have in mind is feasible.

> Roundabout, but it should work (I hope). Note, if you have a validator
> on your java code that tries to lookup the return type, you might get
> some interesting issues.
> 

I don't yet. But I'll keep it in mind to watch out for shell types once I do.

Regards,
Thomas Hallgren