Re: BUG #4562: ts_headline() adds space when parsing url

"Denis Monsieur" <dmonsieur@gmail.com> writes:
> The problem is a space being added to text in the form of
> http://some.url/path
> Compare the output:

> shs=# SELECT ts_headline('http://some.url', to_tsquery('sometext'));
>    ts_headline
> -----------------
>  http://some.url
> (1 row)

> shs=# SELECT ts_headline('http://some.url/path', to_tsquery('sometext'));
>       ts_headline
> -----------------------
>  http:// some.url/path
> (1 row)

I looked into this, and it seems that the problem is that
generateHeadline() emits a space for any token marked as replace = 1.
I think it probably shouldn't emit anything at all.  AFAICS the cases
where replace will get set are token types URL, TAG, NUMHWORD,
ASCIIHWORD, HWORD.  For URL and the HWORD variants the space is
certainly undesirable, because these token types are just respecifying
text that is also covered by their component tokens.  The only case
where you could make an argument that the space is useful is TAG,
as in

regression=# SELECT ts_headline('http<foo>blah', to_tsquery('sometext'));
 ts_headline
-------------
 http blah
(1 row)

But it seems to me to be at least as plausible that you should get
nothing as that you should get a space for a removed tag.

Comments?

            regards, tom lane