Re: Migrating from MaxDB to postgresql

Christopher Browne wrote:
> Quoth John <no@email>:
>
>>As per subject, i'm considering migrating a database (still in
>>development) from MaxDB to postgresql. The main reason for this is
>>that the stored procedures (functions) in MaxDB are unreliable and
>>hard to debug, and that the JDBC driver is still experimental.
>>
>>I thought I'd post here to find out how well functions and JDBC are
>>supported in postgresql.
>>
>>If anyone has info or experience on these two things, I'd be
>>interested to see what your opinion is.
>
>
> Some internal "hackery" has occasionally taken place with JDBC drivers
> that have caused internal consternation (basically due to developers
> needing some new features that were in the "beta" JDBC code), although
> that seems to be fading with 7.4.  And if you don't hack on the
> drivers, you won't get bitten by that sort of thing :-).
>
> The fact that there are easily multiple levels of quoting in stored
> functions certainly makes debugging a bit of a pain, but unreliability
> is not one of the problems observed.  For instance, the Slony-I
> replication system <http://slony.info/> has a considerable portion of
> its code that consists of pl/pgsql stored functions, and it would
> break with great horribleness if stored functions were at all
> "flakey."

Cheers Christopher.

I'll try and resist the hackage and get started with the JDBC. The
quality of the documentation seems good, so I'll have a go at
translating some stored functions this afternoon.

John