Re: Freezing without cleanup lock

Jim Nasby wrote:

> That would be the minimal-impact version, yes. But I suspect if we went
> through the trouble to do that, it would be just as easy to attempt the
> freeze regardless of what scan_all is set to.

You mean if !scan_all we conditional-get the cleanup lock, if we get it
then prune, if not then freeze?  That seems nice on paper but I think
it's useless because unless scan_all is true, then relfrozenxid doesn't
advance anyway.

> What I wish I knew is whether this problem was worth worrying about or not.
> Hopefully the extra logging in 9.5 will shed some light at some point...

As I recall, Andres says it isn't, but I have recollections of scans
that take a very long time to finish because they keep running into a
vacuum that has a page locked.

-- 
Álvaro Herrera                http://www.2ndQuadrant.com/
PostgreSQL Development, 24x7 Support, Remote DBA, Training & Services