Re: UPDATE and outer joins

Bruno Wolff III writes:
> On Wed, Oct 08, 2003 at 12:23:04 +0100,
>   Harry Broomhall <harry.broomhall@uk.easynet.net> wrote:
> >    I wonder if anybody could give me a few pointers on a problem I face.
> >
> >    I need to do an UPDATE on table A, from an effective left outer join
> > on A and another table B.  (This is trying to perform a number translation,
> > where the items that need it are rare.)
> >
> >    The following points *I think* are relevant:
> >
> > 1)  The FROM clause in UPDATE should *only* show additional tables,
> >     otherwise I'll get an extra join I didn't want!  (IMHO this could do
> >     with being emphasised in the docs.)
>
> But that might be the best approach. If you do a left join of A with B in
> the where clause and then an inner join of that result with A you should
> get what you want. If the optimizer does a good job, it may not even be
> much of a hit to do that.

  Er - I though that was one of the points I made - you can't get a
left join in a WHERE clause?  If I am wrong about that then could you
indicate how I might do it?

  I presumed that the left join would have to be in the FROM clause, i.e.:

UPDATE A set cli = num FROM A left join B on (details) WHERE (etc)

  I tried this approach early on, and now I think about it I realize I
didn't have a WHERE clause - which would have done a cross join which would
have taken forever!

  Regards,
    Harry.