Re: [HACKERS] TCL_ARRAYS code in libpgtcl is pretty seriously broken

>
> Massimo Dal Zotto <dz@cs.unitn.it> writes:
> >> [ my gripes about TCL_ARRAYS code snipped ]
>
> > I wrote this code and used it for two years without any problem. All
> > the bugs you mentioned disappear if you use the proper string output
> > functions which C-like escapes (code in contrib/string-io).
>
> Well, not the bug involving overwriting libpq's PGresult storage.
> But still, this explains a good deal.

I didn't realize it could be called more than once for the same tuple.
We must allocate and free a new string for each value. I will write a patch.

> I guess my gripe here is that the TCL_ARRAYS option is enabled *by
> default* in the Postgres distribution, but the code does not work
> properly unless one plugs in a contrib function in the backend
> (and if the connection between the two is documented anywhere, I sure
> didn't see it).  This is not a reasonable default setup.

I submitted the two patches at the same time but one of them was put in the
contribs.

> As a short-term fix I suggest that we just turn off TCL_ARRAYS in
> the distributed config.h.in --- does that sound reasonable to you?

Given the situation I agree that TCL_ARRAYS should be disabled by default.

> In the longer term, there needs to be some way of applying the
> TCL_ARRAYS conversion code only when your contrib stuff is being used.
> Backing the conversion code out of pg_result and making it a separate
> function might do, but that is a low-tech solution that puts the
> responsibility on the application programmer to combine the right bits
> of frontend and backend functionality.  Perhaps someone can think of a
> better way?
>
> Ultimately I would like the text I/O functions to be completely 8-bit
> clean and able to deal with arbitrary byte strings.  That is not
> something we can hope to shoehorn into 6.4, though.

I completely agree on the last thing. It is something I have been asking
from a long time but apparently nobody cared bout it.

--
Massimo Dal Zotto

+----------------------------------------------------------------------+
|  Massimo Dal Zotto                email:  dz@cs.unitn.it             |
|  Via Marconi, 141                 phone:  ++39-461-534251            |
|  38057 Pergine Valsugana (TN)     www:  http://www.cs.unitn.it/~dz/  |
|  Italy                            pgp:  finger dz@tango.cs.unitn.it  |
+----------------------------------------------------------------------+